Scenic British road with car driving through countryside

Why Convicted Driver Insurance Is a Separate Market

Explore your policy choices online today

If you’ve ever had a driving conviction, you’ve probably noticed that getting car insurance can feel like a whole new ball game. It’s not that you can’t get insured, but let’s face it; the process isn’t exactly the same as for someone with a clean record. Convicted driver insurance is, in many ways, a separate world. But why is it so different, and what makes it stand apart from regular car insurance? Let’s unpack it and see why it’s a unique market.

It All Comes Down to Risk

When it comes to insurance, everything revolves around risk. Think of it this way: an insurer is trying to figure out how likely it is that you’ll make a claim. For the average driver, this process is pretty straightforward. Insurers base their assessment on things like your age, where you live, and your driving history.

But for convicted drivers, the equation changes. If you’ve been convicted of something like drink driving or dangerous driving, insurers view you as a higher risk. They’re not just worried about the immediate chance you might file a claim, but they’re also factoring in the possibility that your previous behaviour might repeat. This is why convicted driver insurance exists as its own niche market; because the risk is different and needs to be priced accordingly.

Specialist Insurers for a Specific Need

The good news is that it’s not all doom and gloom. Just because you’ve had a conviction doesn’t mean you’re stuck with sky-high premiums forever. The reason convicted driver insurance is its own market is because there are specialists who focus on offering cover to higher-risk drivers. These companies understand the complexities of insuring people with a conviction history, and they’re more willing to offer you a policy; even if mainstream insurers won’t touch you.

They take a much closer look at your conviction history, driving record, and the details of your situation. This means they can offer you a policy that’s better suited to you, even if you’re paying a little more than someone without a conviction. Specialist insurers have created a niche designed specifically to help drivers like you get back on the road with fairer rates than you might expect.

Why Do Premiums Increase After a Conviction?

You might be wondering: why do my premiums go up after a conviction? Well, it comes down to risk, once again. When insurers calculate premiums, they assess how likely it is that you’ll need to make a claim. If you’ve been convicted of a serious offence like drink-driving or dangerous driving, it’s a signal to the insurer that you’re more likely to make a claim in the future.

But here's the important bit: it’s not about punishing you. Insurers are just trying to cover the risk that comes with insuring someone who has a history of risky behaviour behind the wheel. For instance, if you’ve been convicted of driving without insurance (IN10), insurers may worry you’re not as careful about following the rules, and they’ll raise your premiums to cover that potential risk.

It’s a frustrating reality, but the silver lining is that over time, and with a clean driving record, those premiums can come down.

Rebuilding Trust with Insurers

One thing to keep in mind is that convicted driver insurance isn’t forever. Your first policy after a conviction might cost more, but that doesn’t mean you’re stuck paying through the nose for the rest of your driving life. If you can prove over time that you’re a responsible driver (no more convictions, no claims), you’ll start to see your premiums gradually decrease.

Think of it like rebuilding trust. After a conviction, insurers are cautious. They want to see that you’ve learned from the experience and that you’re unlikely to repeat past mistakes. Keep a clean record, and insurers will start seeing you as less of a risk; and they’ll lower your rates accordingly. So, while convicted driver insurance may seem like a separate market at first, over time it can become just another part of your car insurance journey.

How to Navigate the Convicted Driver Insurance Market

Now, you’re probably wondering: how do you navigate this separate market and find a policy that works for you? Don’t worry; it’s easier than it seems. Here are a few tips to make sure you get the best deal:

Shifting Gears: Moving Beyond Convicted Driver Insurance

While convicted driver insurance is a separate market, it doesn’t have to be a permanent situation. Over time, as your conviction ages and your driving record stays clean, your premiums will gradually reflect that. In the meantime, be honest, shop around, and show insurers you’re committed to being a responsible driver. This way, you can manage your insurance costs and move towards paying a fairer rate.

Convicted driver insurance might feel like a bumpy ride at first, but with patience and a steady driving record, you’ll soon find yourself back on smoother roads.


Visit to read more and get your quote